Skip to the review
The Caribbean Guys — home
EN

Menu

ZEL vs Meliá Punta Cana Beach: Both Scored 8.8, Which I'd Book | 2026

We've stayed at both

ZEL Punta Cana by Meliá & Rafa Nadal
Winner
Meliá Punta Cana Beach Wellness Inclusive
8.8Our scoreZEL Punta Cana by Meliá & Rafa NadalJuly 2026 · suite
8.8Our scoreMeliá Punta Cana Beach Wellness InclusiveOctober 2025 · room with two beds

ZEL wins: 5 of 11 categories, 4 ties. Why

Same score, 8.8, and I'd book ZEL. It wins 5 of the 11 categories we scored at both and they tie 4. If breakfast or a resort without children matters more to you than the room, the Meliá is the one.

  • 5ZEL
  • 4Ties
  • 2Meliá

categories won · Overall 8.8 / 8.8

Which one is for you

Choose ZEL if

  • The room matters to you: probably one of the best rooms we've stayed in, with a hot tub on the terrace and another in the bathroom.
  • You want a small hotel, only 190 rooms, where it feels boutique, not a crowded resort.
  • You're going to move: yoga with a teacher who knows what he's doing, paddle pilates, a 24-hour gym. Or you're bringing slightly older kids who like tennis, padel or activities.

Choose Meliá Punta Cana Beach if

  • Breakfast is your moment of the day: one of the three best I've had in the Caribbean.
  • You want no children in the whole resort: it's strictly 18 and over.
  • You love nature: gardens with peacocks, ducks and lakes, and a wide stretch of beach.

Score by score

Our scores out of 10, from our two reviews. Only the categories we scored at both.

Circled in red: the reason to book it, from its review.

ZELMeliá
  • Cleanliness9.09.5Winner
  • Bed and pillows8.5Winner7.0
  • Bathroom10Winner8.0
  • Breakfast8.09.0Winner
  • Lunch buffet· Tie8.58.5
  • Dinner à la carte· Tie8.58.5
  • All-inclusive, really9.0Winner8.0
  • Pools· Tie9.09.0
  • Adult facilities9.0Winner8.5
  • Staff9.0Winner8.0
  • Beach· Tie8.08.0
  • Overall8.88.8

Face to face, with our score

Our own photos, from our stays. The score is the one we gave that category.

Breakfast

The station for eggs and omelets made to order, at breakfast at ZEL Punta Cana
ZEL8.0
Javier at breakfast at Meliá Punta Cana Beach
Meliá9.0

Pools

One of the pools of ZEL Punta Cana, curving between the palm trees
ZEL9.0
A pool with little islands of palm trees at Meliá Punta Cana Beach, seen from above
Meliá9.0

Beach

The beach in front of ZEL Punta Cana, with loungers under a straw umbrella
ZEL8.0
Palm trees on the wide, white-sand beach of Meliá Punta Cana Beach
Meliá8.0

The bedroom

The bedroom of our room at ZEL Punta Cana, with the hot tub next to the bed
ZEL8.5
Our room at Meliá Punta Cana Beach, with two beds and a window onto the garden
Meliá7.0

ZEL is all suites. At the Meliá we slept in a room with two beds, so they aren't the same category.

Bathroom

The bathroom of our room at ZEL Punta Cana: a double sink and a hot tub
ZEL10
The bathroom at Meliá Punta Cana Beach: sink, towels and a glass shower
Meliá8.0

Dinner à la carte

Steak at the à la carte steakhouse of ZEL Punta Cana
ZEL8.5
The salmon, crispy outside and juicy inside, at an à la carte dinner at Meliá Punta Cana Beach
Meliá8.5

Is either one adults-only?

Winner: Meliá Punta Cana Beach

The Paradisus water park, included for ZEL Punta Cana guests
ZEL
The open-air lobby of Meliá Punta Cana Beach, with its ponds and the Wellness Inclusive sign
Meliá

Meliá Punta Cana Beach is strictly adults-only, 18 and over, the whole resort. Its family version is right next door, the Meliá Caribe Beach: how the two Meliás compare.

ZEL is aimed at adults, wellness and quiet, but families can come too. A few minutes' walk away, ZEL guests can use the Paradisus water park, designed above all for children up to about 8 or 9, and Fun Republic, with trampolines, mini golf and play areas, also included.

If you come with small children and they're your priority, I'd look at the Meliá Caribe first. With slightly older kids who like tennis, padel or activities, ZEL can work.

Which one has the better room?

Winner: ZEL

The living room of our room at ZEL Punta Cana
ZEL
Javier on the terrace of our room at Meliá Punta Cana Beach, facing the garden
Meliá

This is where the gap is biggest. ZEL is all suites, and ours was probably one of the best rooms we've stayed in, and not just in the Dominican Republic: a kitchen-dining area, a big living room, a record player you can use over Bluetooth, a huge terrace with a hot tub and another hot tub in the bathroom. Bathroom 10, bed 8.5.

At the Meliá the room smelled fresh and clean, and the cleaning gets a 9.5, more than ZEL's 9. The bathroom has Rituals products, though the hairdryer is pretty basic, and the bed is correct and functional, a 7.

At ZEL there are a few details to polish: the soap dispensers got stuck, and restocking the small water bottles can take until the next day.

Which one has the better food?

Winner: Meliá Punta Cana Beach

Sushi at the Japanese restaurant of ZEL Punta Cana
ZEL
The tuna tartare at an à la carte dinner at Meliá Punta Cana Beach
Meliá

The Meliá's breakfast is one of the three best I've had in the Caribbean: eggs Benedict with salmon made to order, smoothies blended on the spot, spinach crepes and pata negra ibérico ham. It gets a 9. ZEL's gets an 8: a lighter, Mediterranean breakfast that does its job very well, except for the tortilla de patatas.

Lunch and dinner are closer. The buffets tie at 8.5, and both have homemade pizza; ZEL's is small, because the hotel has only 190 rooms, but almost everything is good. The à la carte dinners also tie at 8.5. At the Meliá the tuna tartare and the salmon were city-restaurant level, but one night the service was slow and they forgot the shrimp in my pasta. At ZEL the steakhouse starters were outstanding, and the mains fell a bit short.

Where ZEL pulls ahead is lunch: its à la carte lunch gets a 9.5, led by Neguri, the beach restaurant, with a rice with beef rib they finish in front of you.

Is it the same beach?

Winner: Meliá Punta Cana Beach

The log entrance to Neguri, ZEL Punta Cana's beach restaurant, on the sand
ZEL
Javier by one of the Balinese beds on the sand at Meliá Punta Cana Beach
Meliá

Yes, the same strip of Bávaro, the one the Meliá hotels in the area share, and we gave both an 8.

The difference is in the stretch. In front of ZEL we saw less shade and fewer loungers than in other parts, though a few minutes' walk gets you more space and natural shade. The Meliá's is wide, with none of the erosion of some neighbors, where the sea reaches the palm trees, and it has Balinese beds with canopies and palapas on the sand. They keep it very clean of sargassum.

The pools tie at 9. ZEL's have shapes, nooks and Balinese beds surrounded by hedges and palm trees; the Meliá's have soft chill-out music and no entertainer shouting. When the seaweed comes and when it doesn't is in our sargassum guide.

Yoga, gym and spa: which one does wellness better?

Winner: ZEL

A yoga class at ZEL Punta Cana, in the room open to the garden
ZEL
The walkway into the YHI Spa at Meliá Punta Cana Beach, with hanging plants and a Buddha
Meliá

Both sell themselves on wellness, and both deliver. Adult facilities: 9 at ZEL, 8.5 at the Meliá.

At ZEL the yoga teacher knows what he's doing: several kinds of yoga, aerial yoga, breathing and mobility classes, and paddle pilates on a board in the water. The gym is open 24 hours, the spa has a thermal circuit, and in the creative workshops you take home a hat or a bag you painted yourself.

The Meliá's Wellness Inclusive is serious too: Pilates, vinyasa yoga in a palapa facing the beach, sunset yoga, healthy cooking workshops and bikes, all included. The YHI Spa's treatments are paid separately.

Which one is quieter?

Winner: Meliá Punta Cana Beach

A Balinese bed under a palapa at ZEL Punta Cana, surrounded by flowering hedges
ZEL
A peacock by one of the lakes at Meliá Punta Cana Beach
Meliá

Neither is a party hotel. ZEL has dance classes, live music and a small bar-club open until 2; the Meliá has shows and a sport bar with a pool table, but no dance floor and no nightclub.

The Meliá is the calmer one: adults only, chill-out music at the pools, and gardens with peacocks, ducks and lakes for a walk at sunset. For peace, it's a 10.

ZEL is quiet in another way: with only 190 rooms, there are lots of corners where you aren't surrounded by people all the time.

Which one is easier to get around?

Winner: ZEL

One of the pools of ZEL Punta Cana, between palapas and palm trees
ZEL
The little train that runs between the lobby and the beach at Meliá Punta Cana Beach
Meliá

ZEL is a much smaller hotel than other Punta Cana resorts, with only 190 rooms: we had time to see practically all of it.

The Meliá is long, running perpendicular to the sea: the lobby is at one end and the beach at the other, with the gardens in between. A little train runs constantly and there are bikes, but if you walk, get ready to sweat a bit at midday. If you have mobility issues, ask for a room near the beach or the pool when you book.

And the staff?

Winner: ZEL

A waiter serving the rice at our table at Neguri, ZEL Punta Cana's beach restaurant
ZEL
Javier at dinner at Meliá Punta Cana Beach, with a waitress at work behind him
Meliá

ZEL's is one of the best teams we've seen in Punta Cana: they don't serve you once and disappear, they keep coming by the table. A 9.

The Meliá's surprised me too, with a friendliness that felt real and staff who anticipated what I needed. It gets an 8 because the service at the à la carte dinner needs to be faster.

Prices for your dates

Both resorts for the same dates, with taxes and resort fees included.

ZEL Punta Cana by Meliá & Rafa Nadal

Add your dates to see the price.

See rooms at ZEL8.8Read our ZEL reviewEvery photo, every score, the good and the bad
Meliá Punta Cana Beach Wellness Inclusive

Add your dates to see the price.

See rooms at Meliá8.8Read our Meliá reviewEvery photo, every score, the good and the bad

Questions we get

How far are ZEL and Meliá Punta Cana Beach from Punta Cana Airport?
About 25 minutes by car, both of them. It isn't a reason to choose between them.
Which one is better for a couple?
Both are made for couples who want to rest. ZEL if you'll spend time in the room, with its hot tub on the terrace. The Meliá if you want sunset walks through the gardens and no children anywhere in the resort.
Do you need to book the à la carte restaurants?
At the Meliá, yes: the dinners have no limit, but you book them 24 hours ahead, so do it as soon as you arrive. At ZEL the à la carte lunch restaurants need no reservation, and for dinner I recommend booking the steakhouse and the Japanese one.
Which one is cheaper?
It depends on the dates. Put yours in the price box on this page and you'll see both, side by side.

Members' rate for Punta Cana

Join our newsletter: the members' rate, plus tricks and tips you only find out by staying at the resort.

Written by Javier Sobrino
Updated Oct 2026 · most of our stays we paid for ourselves · how we score

Dates & guests

Adults
2
Children
0

Prices update for your dates. Nothing added later.