Skip to the review
The Caribbean Guys — home
EN

Menu

Secrets Cap Cana vs Hyatt Zilara: We've Stayed at Both | 2026

We've stayed at both

Secrets Cap Cana
Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana
Winner
8.9Our scoreSecrets Cap CanaOctober 2026 · room with two Queen beds
9.4Our scoreHyatt Zilara Cap CanaJuly 2026 · Master Suite

Zilara wins: 9 of 12 categories, 3 ties. Why

The Hyatt Zilara wins. It beats Secrets in 9 of the 12 categories we scored at both and ties the other 3. Secrets comes close: if the Zilara is much more expensive for your dates, it's a very good alternative.

  • 0Secrets
  • 3Ties
  • 9Zilara

categories won · Overall 8.9 / 9.4

Which one is for you

Choose Secrets Cap Cana if

  • The Hyatt's price for your dates is through the roof. If they're close, I'd book the Hyatt.
  • You like having a sky bar to watch the sunset with a cocktail.
  • You want a tub on your terrace: our room had one, and it wasn't a suite.

Choose Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana if

  • You want the safest bet in Punta Cana: it's the best hotel we've stayed in to date.
  • Food comes first: our first 10 for a breakfast, and most à la carte restaurants need no booking.
  • You want more to do: the Ziva next door adds restaurants, bars and water slides, and its kids can't come into the Zilara.

Score by score

Our scores out of 10, from our two reviews. Only the categories we scored at both.

Circled in red: the reason to book it, from its review.

SecretsZilara
  • Cleanliness9.510Winner
  • Bed and pillows9.09.5Winner
  • Bathroom9.09.5Winner
  • Room size· Tie8.58.5
  • Breakfast8.510Winner
  • Lunch buffet8.59.5Winner
  • Dinner à la carte9.09.5Winner
  • All-inclusive, really9.09.5Winner
  • Pools· Tie9.09.0
  • Adult facilities9.09.5Winner
  • Staff9.09.5Winner
  • Beach· Tie9.09.0
  • Overall8.99.4

Face to face, with our score

Our own photos, from our stays. The score is the one we gave that category.

Breakfast

Eggs Benedict at breakfast at Secrets Cap Cana
Secrets8.5
Javier at breakfast at the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana
Zilara10

Pools

The pools, the gardens and the sea at Secrets Cap Cana, from above
Secrets9.0
The infinity pool of the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana at sunset
Zilara9.0

Beach

The beach at Secrets Cap Cana, with the Secrets sign on the sand
Secrets9.0
White sand and palm trees on Playa Juanillo, in front of the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana
Zilara9.0

Dinner à la carte

Tagliatelle with pesto at the Italian restaurant of Secrets Cap Cana
Secrets9.0
Sea bass at the French restaurant of the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana
Zilara9.5

The standard room

Our room with two Queen beds at Secrets Cap Cana
Secrets8.5
A standard room at the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana, with a king bed and the door to the terrace
Zilara8.5

Both are 56 m². At Secrets ours also had a tub on the terrace; the Zilara's standard room doesn't.

Is the Zilara really adults-only, with the family Ziva next door?

Tie

One of the pools of Secrets Cap Cana on a busy afternoon
Secrets
The Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana seen from the beach, with loungers on the sand
Zilara

Yes. The Zilara is the adults-only side of the Hyatt complex, and the Ziva, right next door, is the family side. Kids staying at the Ziva can't come into the Zilara, so you won't see any at your pool or your restaurants.

It works the other way round: staying at the Zilara, you can go over to the Ziva for its restaurants, bars and activities, and even its water slides. You get an adults-only hotel and double the offer.

Secrets is adults-only from end to end, the whole resort. It isn't huge, so everything is relatively close and you don't need the electric cart to get around.

Which one has the better food?

Winner: Hyatt Zilara

The leg of serrano ham at breakfast at Secrets Cap Cana
Secrets
The buffet of the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana, with hanging hams over the tables
Zilara

This is where the gap is biggest. The Zilara's breakfast is the first one we've ever given a 10: you go round the stations and they serve you, so everything stays clean and orderly. At Secrets breakfast is very good, with serrano ham and eggs Benedict, but the orange juice isn't freshly squeezed.

For dinner, the Zilara's Indian, with a chef from India, and its French, with one of the best foies I've tried, beat what we ate at Secrets. There, the Italian was the one we liked most, and the Japanese was fine, but not top.

At the Zilara, at most restaurants you don't need to book, and we never had to wait. At Secrets, book the French as soon as you arrive: it's the most requested, and we missed it.

Beach and pools: is there a difference?

Tie

The infinity pool of Secrets Cap Cana, right in front of the beach
Secrets
One of the hot jacuzzis by the main pool of the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana
Zilara

It's the same beach. Along Playa Juanillo you have the Zilara, then the Ziva, then Secrets. White, fine sand that doesn't burn, lots of space and loungers: a 9 at both.

The pools also tie, at 9. The Zilara's infinity pool faces the beach, with a swim-up bar in the shade and two hot jacuzzis looking at the sea. Secrets has two connected areas: a lake-style pool that gets deeper little by little, for games and aquagym, and a big infinity pool onto the sea, with small islands for some privacy.

We were at the Zilara in July, with some sargassum, though the water never felt dirty. When it comes and when it doesn't is in our sargassum guide.

Which one is quieter?

Winner: Secrets Cap Cana

Sunset from the sky bar of Secrets Cap Cana
Secrets
Archery on the beach at the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana
Zilara

Neither is a party hotel. Both are for couples and adults who want good food, pool, beach and quiet. At Secrets the evenings bring shows and live singers, and one night we even had live music on the beach.

Secrets is quiet, relaxed and romantic: the pools generally have no music, there are romantic corners everywhere, and the sky bar on the top floor is the place for the sunset. Its spa is small, but a waiter brings your drink to you in the circuit.

The Zilara has more going on: archery, kayaks and paddle surfing included, a sports bar where you actually want to sit, and the Ziva next door. If what you want is a party, neither: Breathless Punta Cana.

Which one has the better rooms?

Winner: Hyatt Zilara

The double sink of our bathroom at Secrets Cap Cana
Secrets
The bathroom at the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana, with two sinks
Zilara

Both standard rooms are 56 m², so size is a tie. We slept in a Master Suite at the Zilara and a room with two Queen beds at Secrets, but they let us film a standard room at the Zilara too: even that one is spectacular, and it still wins on bed and bathroom.

At Secrets the room is big and boutique-style, with a terrace and a tub outside. You get two pillows per bed, no more, and slippers for everyone in the room.

Both have rooms that open onto a semi-private pool, shared with other rooms. At Secrets, if you want privacy, better the one with a terrace.

And the staff?

Winner: Hyatt Zilara

A bartender making cocktails at Secrets Cap Cana
Secrets
The bar of a cocktail workshop at the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana
Zilara

Both are excellent. At Secrets everyone we spoke to had very good English, and the service is a level above most resorts. The Zilara's is the best staff we've seen in Punta Cana, attentive without being annoying, and the friendliness never feels forced.

Prices for your dates

Both resorts for the same dates, with taxes and resort fees included.

Secrets Cap Cana

Add your dates to see the price.

See rooms at Secrets8.9Read our Secrets reviewEvery photo, every score, the good and the bad
Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana

Add your dates to see the price.

See rooms at Zilara9.4Read our Zilara reviewEvery photo, every score, the good and the bad

Questions we get

How far are Secrets Cap Cana and Hyatt Zilara from Punta Cana Airport?
Around 15 minutes to the Zilara and about 17 to Secrets.
Is room service included?
Yes, at both, at no extra cost.
Which one is better for a honeymoon?
Both work. The Zilara is the safer bet. Secrets isn't huge and is very romantic, with pools that generally have no music, a sky bar for the sunset and, in our room, a tub on the terrace.
When is the sargassum season on that beach?
We were at the Zilara in July, which isn't the best time for it: there was some seaweed, though the water never felt dirty. The good season is roughly from November to April.
What is the spa like?
At Secrets it's small and more for massages, with nine kinds of hydrotherapy jets and a waiter who brings your drink to the circuit. At the Zilara they didn't let us film the spa, so we can't give an opinion on it.
Which one is cheaper?
It depends on the dates. Put yours in the price box on this page and you'll see both, side by side.

Members' rate for Punta Cana

Join our newsletter: the members' rate, plus tricks and tips you only find out by staying at the resort.

Written by Javier Sobrino
Updated Nov 2026 · most of our stays we paid for ourselves · how we score

Dates & guests

Adults
2
Children
0

Prices update for your dates. Nothing added later.